Painful loss in the human vs computer-vision battle

A computer-vision system has been found to be 30 per cent better than humans at identifying if an expression of pain is real or faked. This could be used to uncover pain fabrication within security, law, and medicine.

Human observers were asked to deduce the veracity of expressions of pain of individuals who were either undergoing cold presser tests -- which involves the hand of the individual being placed in ice water for a period of time -- or were told to fake painful expressions. In total 205 human observers were asked to decide whether the pain was real. The cold presser test is a common method to measure pain tolerance of a subject.

The research was published in the most recent edition of Current Biology. The authors were: Dr Marian Bartlett, research professor, Institute for Neural Computation, University of California, San Diego; Dr Gwen Littlewort, co-director of the institute’s Machine Perception Laboratory; Dr Mark Frank, professor of communication, University at Buffalo, and Dr Kang Lee, Dr Erick Jackman Institute of Child Study, University of Toronto.

The researchers employed the computer expression recognition toolbox (CERT), an end-to-end system for fully automated facial-expression recognition that operates in real time. It was developed by Bartlett, Littlewort, Frank and others to assess the accuracy of machine versus human vision.

The research found that, even after training, the observers were only 55 per cent accurate at deciding whether the facial expression was a real or fake and before training were less successful than if the decisions had been left to chance. The vision system on the other hand made the correct decision 85 per cent of the time.

Bartlett commented: ‘[The system] managed to detect distinctive, dynamic features of facial expressions that people missed. Human observers just aren’t very good at telling real from faked expressions of pain.’ He continued to say that the system ‘can be applied to detect states in which the human face may provide important clues as to health, physiology, emotion or thought, such as drivers’ expressions of sleepiness, students’ expressions of attention and comprehension of lectures, or responses to treatment of affective disorders.’

Twitter icon
Google icon icon
Digg icon
LinkedIn icon
Reddit icon
e-mail icon

Gareth Powell, marketing manager for the high performance imaging division at e2v


Matthew Dale speaks to Specim about the burgeoning industrial spectral imaging camera market


Rob Ashwell on the advances being made in robot guidance, from the rise of robotics in warehouses to lighting control for robot-vision systems


Greg Blackman looks at the intricacies of inspecting fabrics, a market that offers big returns on investment for an automated vision system if it can deal with product variation


Matthew Dale finds that optical inspection techniques are improving upkeep and the running of rail networks